Decision
As my USG-3P was getting on in age and no longer getting updates, I have been shopping around for a replacement. Below were the main competitors for me.
UXG-Lite:
- Price: $129 (plus tax and shipping)
- WiFi: None
- Unifi controller: No
- CPU: Two A53 cores at 1 GHz
- Memory: 1 GB of DDR3L
- Storage: N/A
- IPS/IDS max throughput: claimed 1Gbps (subject to third party verification)
- Unifi Protect: No support
- Price: $199 (plus tax and shipping)
- WiFi: 6 (however, this was to be deployed in my basement so not much help)
- Unifi controller: Yes
- CPU: Two A53 cores at 1.35 GHz
- Memory: 2 GB of ?DDR3L?
- Storage: 128 GB SSD
- IPS/IDS max throughput: ~700Mbps
- Unifi Protect: would need a SD card
- Price: $379 --Black Friday $279-- (plus tax and shipping)
- WiFi: No
- Unifi controller: Yes
- CPU: Four A57 cores at 1.7 GHz
- Memory: 4 GB of DDR4
- Storage: 16 GB eMMC
- IPS/IDS max throughput: ~3.5Gbps
- Unifi Protect: Hard drive slot
- Bonus: LAN + WAN SFP+ ports for 10Gbps networking
Initial Impressions
- Shipping box contained lots of air pillows
- High quality foam protecting the device in device packaging
- Build quality is superb
- Slide out foam screw holder was a nice organizational touch
- Single use plastics used to wrap:
- UDM Pro itself
- Rack mount ears
- Instructions, really????
Installation
- This guide was written using Unifi Network 8.0.7
- USG-3P network address is 192.168.1.1
- Unifi controller is hosted at https://192.168.1.2:8443
- Internet connection
- Laptop with an ethernet port or a PC that can be hardwired
- 2x ethernet cords (Only 1 is needed if you have an already hardwired PC)
- Create a backup from your current Unifi controller on a laptop
- Navigate to https://192.168.1.2:8443
- Settings -> System -> Backups
- Click on `Download`
- Select number of days (I chose 7)
- Click `Download`
- Connect a LAN port on your current network to the WAN port on UDM Pro
- This is to provide it with internet access
- Power on the UDM Pro
- Allow it to update (this took several minutes)
- Connect a laptop to the LAN port on the UDM Pro
- May be helpful to disable WiFi on laptop
- Setup Wizard on UDM Pro
- Navigate to https://unifi/ (for me https://192.168.0.1 also would have worked)
- Login with your Unifi account
- Do NOT restore from Backup, skip this step
- Finish the setup Wizard
- Update the Network Application
- You want it to be >= Unifi controller Network version
- Restore the backup
- Network -> Settings -> System -> Backups
- Click on `Restore`
- Select the backup you created above
- Click on `Restore`
- UDM Pro will restart
- UDM Pro web UI will become unresponsive
- At this point I used the touch screen to reboot the UDM Pro
- However, this could be unnecessary and may possibly be resolved by forcing the laptop to get a new DHCP address
- Ensure your restore happened correctly
- Navigate to https://192.168.1.1
- Check that the network settings are correct and that your access points are there (but they won't be connected)
- Swap out the USG-3P for the UDM Pro
- Migrate the Access Points from Unifi controller to UDM Pro
- Navigate to https://192.168.1.2:8443
- Settings -> General
- Click on `Export Site` on the bottom
- You can save the export file, but we won't be using it
- Click continue on the `Export Site` dialog
- Click continue on the `Migrate Site` dialog (no action needed)
- Type in the IP address of the UDM Pro (192.168.1.1)
- Select the Access Points to migrate
- Click `Migrate Devices`
- Check in another tab/window that they migrated to the UDM Pro
- Click on `Remove Devices`
- Done!
Overall Impressions
- The migration went smoothly, once I pieced together what needed done
- Network performance is great
- IPS has already started blocking network scans
- Will not fit in a 12" rack that is flush mounted
- AC plug is very far to one side and almost didn't have enough clearance for the 2x4 supporting my network rack, wish it was more centered
- Possibly could be resolved by a 90 degree power connector
- There doesn't seem to be a way to manage the screen
- It will go into a screensaver mode during the day and turn off at night
- However, I cannot find settings to change the times for this behavior
- Update 2024-01-04:
- To change this you have to set the local account as "Super Admin" on https://unifi.ui.com -> UDM Pro -> OS Settings (At the top looks like a UDM Pro with a gear icon on the bottom right) -> Admins & Users
- Then you can update it https://192.168.1.1/console-settings
- I set night mode to start at 10:01 PM and end at 10:00 PM thus keeping the screen off for most of the day
- Lack of detailed official documentation on migration process
- Topology is wrong because I have a non-Unifi switch and there isn't a way to manually fix
- https://www.reddit.com/r/UNIFI/comments/yfyrib/good_current_guide_to_migrate_to_a_new_controller/
- https://fydelia.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/360011466220-Migrating-UniFi-APs-to-another-controller
- https://help.ui.com/hc/en-us/articles/360008976393-UniFi-How-to-Migrate-from-Cloud-Key-to-Cloud-Key-or-UDM
- https://reimling.eu/2022/01/migrate-ubiquiti-unifi-security-gateway-usg-to-unifi-dream-machine-pro-udm-pro/
- https://community.ui.com/questions/Unable-to-uninstall-install-applications-on-UDM-Pro/54f23f0e-9500-44fc-8516-c130986ff24a


